Archives for October 2012

Concerned Employer may have Violated the ADA by Ordering Employee to Seek Counseling, Sixth Circuit Finds

By Kate Acheson

In Kroll v. White Lake Ambulance Authority, the Sixth Circuit found that an employer’s order for an Emergency Medical Technician (“EMT”) to attend counseling for suspected depression may have been an impermissible “medical examination” in violation of the Americans with Disabilities Act (“ADA”).  The case was remanded to determine whether an ADA exception allowing “job related” medical examinations that are consistent with a “business necessity” applies. [Read more…]

Eighth Circuit Rejects Officer’s First Amendment Claims Arising from Completed Police Report

By Kate Acheson

A Missouri Police Officer who was passed over for a promotion and other positive job benefits, claimed the City was retaliating against him for reporting City official corruption in an internal investigation report.  In Buehrle v. City of O’Fallon, Mo., the Eighth Circuit concluded that the First Amendment did not protect the Officer’s speech, which was made in the course of his official duties, and upheld a summary judgment dismissing his claims.

[Read more…]

NY District Court Refuses to Flush Excessive Urine Test Complaint

By Kate Acheson

After being subjected to repeated urine-sample drug tests, a New York Metropolitan Transportation Authority (“MTA”) Officer, Ada Perez, filed complaint.  The MTA moved to dismiss.  In Perez v. Metro. Transp. Auth., the District Court for the Southern District of New York refused to dismiss Officer Perez’s complaint, reasoning that sufficient information existed for a jury to find in Officer Perez’s favor on her unreasonable search and seizure claim.

[Read more…]

Turning the Tables on Discrimination: Reverse Discrimination Making Headlines in the Wake of Ricci v. DeStefano Decision

By Cynthia McNabb

As suspected when the United States Supreme Court ruled in 2009, in the case of Ricci v. DeStefano, reverse discrimination cases among police and firefighters are in the headlines, with several verdicts reached favoring the plaintiffs who have brought reverse discrimination cases against their employers.

[Read more…]

Testing the Limits of the ADA on Prescription Drug Use: EEOC Reaches Significant Settlement on Workplace Testing for Prescription Drugs

By Cynthia McNabb

Are you required to drug test in order to keep your job?  In addition to drug testing, are you required to disclose what prescription medication you are taking and for what purpose?  If you answered yes to any of these questions, a recent EEOC settlement reached, may be of interest to you.

[Read more…]

Ninth Circuit Breaks from Trend, Suggests Placement on Administrative Leave Could Constitute “Adverse Employment Action”

By Kate Acheson

Public employees are protected in the exercise of their First Amendment rights. This allows them to bring lawsuits when an employer’s retaliatiatory action is significant enough to constitute an “adverse employment action.”  Not every employer action rises to that level. 

[Read more…]