Search Results for: kitsap

Court Upholds Arbitration Award and Rules Connecticut Police Officer’s Lie Not Bad Enough to Violate Public Policy

By: Jim Cline and Geoff Kiernan

In Town of Stratford (Connecticut), the City attempted to vacate an arbitration decision that had reinstated a police officer who was discharged for lying to an independent neurologist by withholding medical information about his seizures and alcohol abuse.  The City argued that the police officer must be fired because there is a public policy against intentional dishonesty in connection with police employment. The Court agreed that while there was a public policy against intentional policy officer dishonesty in connection with employment, the dishonesty at issue here was not so extreme as to make the arbitrator’s award a violation of public policy.

[Read more…]

Ohio Appeals Court Vacates Arbitrators Award that Reinstated Firefighter with Asthma

By Jim Cline and Jordan L. Jones

blown-candleIn City of St. Marys v. Fire Fighters Local 3633, the Ohio Court of Appeals vacated an arbitrator’s award which had reinstated an asthmatic firefighter. The arbitrator had found that the party’s fitness testing language had not been complied with but the Court determined that the arbitrator exceeded his authority in reaching that result.

[Read more…]

Ohio Arbitrator’s Creativity in Awarding “Involuntary Resignation” within Her Lawful Discretion

By Anthony Rice

 ArbitrationOhio Patrolmen’s Benevolent Ass’n v. City of Trenton, the Court of Appeals of Ohio upheld an arbitration award ordering the “involuntary resignation” of a police sergeant. The unusual case led to an unusual remedy which the union then unsuccessfully sought to have set aside in court. [Read more…]